The Dark Side
Frontline, PBS, broadcast
June 20, 2006
Amid revelations about faulty prewar intelligence and a scandal surrounding the indictment of the vice president's
chief of staff and presidential adviser, I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby, FRONTLINE goes behind the headlines to investigate the
internal war that was waged between the intelligence community and Richard Bruce Cheney, the most powerful vice president in the nation's history
Please wait a moment for the videos to load
click play to view
Within Hours of 9/11...
Dick Cheney seizes the initiative, George Tenet pulls out the CIA's already architected plan for attacking the
Taliban and Al Qaeda in Afghanistan, and Donald Rumsfeld puts Iraq on the table.
Behind Closed Doors
Conflicts surface between the CIA and military during the Afghanistan war against the Taliban, but the war is deemed
a CIA success story. Meanwhile Cheney works to undercut Tenet's CIA by building his own intelligence capability.
The Push for War in Iraq
In Afghanistan, bin Laden escapes and the CIA blames the military. At the Pentagon, its secret intelligence unit funnels
Iraq information through Cheney's office. Cheney continues to assert an Iraq-Al Qaeda connection, but the CIA denies it.
The National Intelligence Estimate (NIE)
At the request of Congress, which is nearing a vote on war, Tenet produces an NIE on the evidence of Iraq's WMD programs.
The president has doubts about its strength. Tenet assures him it's a 'slam dunk.'
Flawed Intelligence Goes Public
The questionable analysis on Iraq's WMD threat makes its way into Bush's State of the Union speech. It also gets into
Powell's U.N. address on the case for war, even though Powell personally had questioned the CIA about the evidence.
A Covert Campaign
No WMD is found in Iraq. In June 2004, Tenet resigns. Tensions grow between the CIA and Cheney loyalists. The 'Scooter'
Libby investigation uncovers what appears to be a covert campaign waged against the CIA by the Office of the Vice President.
"A lot of what needs to be done here will have to be done quietly, without any discussion, using sources and methods that
are available to our intelligence agencies," Cheney told Americans just after 9/11. He warned the public that the government
would have to operate on the "dark side."
In "The Dark Side," FRONTLINE tells the story of the vice president's role as the chief architect of the war on terror,
and his battle with Director of Central Intelligence George Tenet for control of the "dark side." Drawing on more than 40 interviews and thousands of documents, the film provides a step-by-step
examination of what happened inside the councils of war.
Early in the Bush administration, Cheney placed a group of allies throughout the government who advocated a robust and pre-emptive foreign policy, especially regarding Iraq. But a potential obstacle was Tenet, a holdover
from the Clinton administration who had survived the transition by bypassing Cheney and creating a personal bond with the
After the attacks on 9/11, Cheney seized the initiative and pushed for expanding presidential power, transforming America's
intelligence agencies and bringing the war on terror to Iraq. Cheney's primary ally in this effort was Secretary of Defense
"You have this wiring diagram that we all know of about national security, but now there's a new line on it. There's a
line from the vice president directly to the secretary of defense, and it's as though there's a private line, private communication
between those two," former National Security Council staffer Richard Clarke tells FRONTLINE.
In the initial stages of the war on terror, Tenet's CIA was rising to prominence as the lead agency in the Afghanistan
war. But when Tenet insisted in his personal meetings with the president that there was no connection between Al Qaeda and
Iraq, Cheney and Rumsfeld initiated a secret program to re-examine the evidence and marginalize the agency and Tenet. Through
interviews with DoD staffers who sifted through mountains of raw intelligence, FRONTLINE details how questionable intelligence was "stovepiped" to the
vice president and presented to the public.
From stories of Iraq buying yellowcake uranium from Niger to claims that 9/11 hijacker Mohamed Atta had met with an Iraqi
agent in Prague, "The Dark Side" dissects the now-familiar assertions that led the nation to war. The program also receounts
the vice president's unprecedented visits to the CIA, where he questioned mid-level analysts on their conclusions. CIA officers
who were there at the time say the message was clear: Cheney wanted evidence that Iraq was a threat.
At the center of the administration's case for war was a classified October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate that found evidence of an Iraqi weapons of mass destruction program. But Paul Pillar, one of the report's principal authors, now admits to FRONTLINE that the NIE was written quickly in a highly politicized environment,
one in which the decision to go to war had already been made. Pillar also reveals that he regrets participating in writing
a subsequent public "white paper" on Iraqi WMD. "What was the purpose of it? The purpose was to strengthen the case for going
to war with the American public. Is it proper for the intelligence community to publish papers for that purpose? I don't think
so, and I regret having had a role in it," Pillar says.
For the first time, FRONTLINE tells of George Tenet's personal struggle in the run-up to the Iraq war through the accounts
of his closest advisers.
"He, I think, asked himself whether or not he wanted to continue on that road and to be part of it. And I think there was
a lot of agonizing that George went through about what would be in the best interest of the country and national interest,
or whether or not he would stay in that position and continue along a course that I think he had misgivings about," says John Brennan, former deputy executive director of the CIA.
Tenet chose to stay, but after the failure to find Iraqi WMD, the tension between the agency and Cheney's allies grew to
the point that some in the administration believed the CIA had launched a covert war to undermine the president. In response,
Cheney's office waged a campaign to distance itself from the prewar intelligence the vice president had helped to cultivate.
Under pressure, Tenet resigned. Cheney's chief of staff, Scooter Libby, would later admit to leaking key sections of the NIE
-- authorized, he says, by Cheney. Libby also stated that the vice president told him that President Bush had declassified
the material. Insiders tell FRONTLINE that the leak was part of the battle between the vice president and the CIA -- a battle
that many believe has destroyed the CIA.