By Any Means Necessary:
The United States And Japan
If Hiroshima and Nagasaki
had not worked, the US had a plan that involved massive use of chemical weaponsby Paul Rogers
24, 2005Open Democracy The dropping of the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August 1945 remains a focus of historical controversy
even sixty years later. Until the 1970s, most historians accepted the view that the weapons were used to prevent the need
for an American invasion of the Japanese mainland scheduled to start in November 1945. Subsequently, “revisionist”
critics argued that there were other motives, not least the need to bring the war to an early end because of the rise of Soviet influence
in the region. In this view, Hiroshima and Nagasaki were early shots in the cold war, at a time when Japan was actually close to surrender.
later generation of historians argued that the release of previously secret intelligence material dating from early 1945 establishes
that Japan was not ready to surrender, and that its army planned to defend the homeland so formidably, and at such cost to
American invaders, that Japan could force a ceasefire on favourable terms (see Richard B Frank, "Why Truman Dropped the Bomb",
, 8 August 2005
The arguments and counter-arguments will not easily be concluded, and it is certainly the case that the United States
was prepared to continue the use of atomic weapons against Japanese cities until surrender was forced; the Manhattan Project
was thought to be capable of producing two more atom bombs a month through to the end of 1945. In the event, the formal Japanese surrender
on 2 September 1945 brought the war to an end without further nuclear attacks.
But what would have happened if the
Manhattan Project had not had its effect and the United States’s projected invasion of Japan had indeed gone ahead?
The sudden end of the war precipitated by the two atomic bombs, and subsequent secrecy on the part of the United States, disguised
for many years the fact that the US had prepared a remarkable back-up plan. This was the mass-production of enormous quantities
of chemical weapons to be used against Japanese cities, that envisaged killing as many as 5 million people.
secret plan came to light with the declassification of sensitive papers after the end of the cold war, and was written up
some years later in a paper for the authoritative Proceedings of the US Naval Institute
by two military historians, Norman Polmar & Thomas B Allen ("The Most Deadly Plan", Proceedings
, January 1998
It scarcely reached the public domain at the time, yet it says much about the approach to warfare that had developed
by 1945, including a willingness to inflict mass civilian casualties on a scale far higher even than the carpet-bombing of
, Hamburg or Dresden or the atom bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.A chemical blitz
the war in Europe was being fought to a bitter end during the winter of 1944-45, there was still uncertainty that the Manhattan
Project would succeed in its aim of producing atomic weapons. By early 1945, plans were already underway for an American invasion
of the Japanese mainland, “Operation Olympic
” (the first part of the wider “Operation Downfall
”), which was to start with the southern island of Kyushu.
The high American death toll in the much smaller invasions
of the Marianas, Iwo Jima, Okinawa and elsewhere led the US army's Chemical Warfare Service
to devise a plan to use massive chemical weapon attacks to support the invasion of the mainland.
were contained in A Study of the Possible Use of Toxic Gas in Operation Olympic
, an anodyne title for an extraordinary
proposal that involved two different if almost simultaneous uses for thousands of tons of chemical weapons. The main weapons
to be used were two chemical blister agents, phosgene and mustard gas, together with hydrogen cyanide and cyanogen chloride.
the time of the invasion itself, tactical strike aircraft would drop nearly 9,000 tons of chemical weapons on the defending
troops in the first fifteen days, with further attacks planned at the rate of just under 5,000 tons every thirty days from
then on. As US troops came ashore, they would bring in howitzers and mortars that could deliver an additional forty-five tons
a day of poisonous gas on Japanese positions.
This represented a massive use of chemical weapons, but it was dwarfed
in scale by the proposed attacks on Japanese cities. In what the document described as an "initial gas blitz", long-range
B-29 and B-24 strategic bombers would attack a large number of cities across Japan – starting with Tokyo, fifteen days
before the ground invasion started. Over the next, initial fifteen-day period, over 56,000 tons of gas bombs would be dropped
on cities, followed by almost 24,000 tons of gas bombs dropped every month from then on until the war ended or all the planned
targets had been hit.
Although this plan
was completed only in June 1945, it originated in work started by the Chemical Warfare Service more than eighteen months
earlier; as early as April 1944, a detailed study – Selected Aerial Objectives for Retaliatory Gas Attacks on Japan
– had been completed assessing the vulnerability of cities such as Tokyo, Nagoya and Osaka to gas attack. The analysts
believed that their densely populated residential areas, with narrow streets and few open spaces, were particularly susceptible
to chemical warfare. Moreover, mustard gas is readily absorbed by wood, and Japanese wooden houses would have been very difficult
The intention was to maximise casualties
, mostly civilian, and the study stated:
By June 1945, the full gas-attack plan was submitted to Major General William N Porter
, head of the Chemical Warfare Service, detailing fifty urban and industrial targets, including twenty-five cities that were
particularly susceptible to gas attack. According to the report, "Gas attacks of the size and intensity recommended on these
250 square miles of urban population … might easily kill 5,000,000 people and injure that many more."
warfare attacks were never implemented, but the programme was in no sense theoretical. While the plans were being formulated,
much effort was put into manufacturing and stockpiling the weapons so that they would be ready if needed. The first chemical
weapon plant had been opened in April 1944
at Warners, New York state, initially producing about eighty tons of poison gas a week. This was later increased to over
400 tons a week, and more plants were built so that by 1945 the US army had over fifty million chemical artillery shells and
the US army air corps had more than a million bombs and 100,000 aircraft spray tanks.
The dropping of the atom bombs
on Hiroshima and Nagasaki remains controversial to this day. The fact that many more atom bombs would have been used against
Japanese cities if the imperial government had not surrendered when it did indicates the determination of the US leadership
to end the war with the lowest possible American casualties, whatever happened in Japan.
If the Manhattan Project
had not succeeded in producing "Little Boy" and "Fat Man", then "Plan B" was waiting in the wings, potentially capable of
killing even more people than died in Hiroshima, Nagasaki, or the firebombing
Copyright Paul Rogers 2005
This article is published by Paul Rogers
, and openDemocracy.net
under a Creative Commons licence. You may republish it free of charge with attribution for non-commercial purposes following
. If you teach at a university we ask that your department make a donation
. Commercial media must contact us for permission
and fees. Some articles on this site are published under different terms.
This article originally appeared on
under a Creative Commons licence. To view the original article, please click here